Request Quote
(Ships tomorrow)
2SA1837,WNLF(J) Equivalent & Substitute Parts
Part Overview
The 2SA1837,WNLF(J) is a PNP bipolar junction transistor manufactured by Toshiba Semiconductor and Storage, rated for 230 V collector-emitter breakdown voltage and 1 A maximum collector current. This component is packaged in a TO-220-3 through-hole configuration and is designed for general-purpose switching and amplification applications requiring moderate power dissipation up to 2 W.
The 2SA1837,WNLF(J) is classified as obsolete. Identifying equivalent substitute parts is necessary to maintain design continuity, ensure supply chain availability, and support ongoing production or repair requirements for legacy systems utilizing this transistor.
Substiute Parts
Key Parameters
| Parameter | Value | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Transistor Type | PNP | — |
| Voltage - Collector Emitter Breakdown (Max) | 230 | V |
| Current - Collector (Ic) (Max) | 1 | A |
| Power - Max | 2 | W |
| Frequency - Transition | 70 | MHz |
| Operating Temperature (TJ) | 150 | °C |
| Mounting Type | Through Hole | — |
| Package / Case | TO-220-3 | — |
| Moisture Sensitivity Level (MSL) | 1 (Unlimited) | — |
Substitute Part Grouping Explanation
Substitution of the 2SA1837,WNLF(J) is evaluated based on the following electrical and mechanical parameters:
Transistor Type: Both the main part and substitute must be PNP-type bipolar junction transistors to maintain circuit polarity and biasing requirements.
Voltage Rating: The substitute part must meet or exceed the 230 V collector-emitter breakdown voltage specification to ensure safe operation within the original design envelope.
Current Rating: The substitute part must support the maximum collector current requirement of 1 A or higher to handle the specified load conditions.
Power Dissipation: The substitute part must be rated for 2 W or greater power handling to accommodate thermal requirements.
Frequency Response: The substitute part must support the 70 MHz transition frequency or higher to maintain signal integrity in high-frequency applications.
Package Configuration: The substitute part must use the TO-220-3 through-hole package to ensure mechanical and thermal compatibility with existing printed circuit board layouts.
Operating Temperature: The substitute part must support the 150°C maximum junction temperature rating.
The 2SA1668 from Sanken Electric USA Inc. is evaluated against these criteria as a potential substitute.
Parameter Comparison
| Parameter | 2SA1837,WNLF(J) (Main Part) | 2SA1668 (Substitute) | Compatibility Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Transistor Type | PNP | PNP | Match |
| Voltage - Collector Emitter Breakdown (Max) | 230 V | 200 V | Substitute rated lower |
| Current - Collector (Ic) (Max) | 1 A | 2 A | Substitute exceeds requirement |
| Vce Saturation (Max) | 1.5 V @ 50mA, 500mA | 1 V @ 70mA, 700mA | Substitute performs better |
| Current - Collector Cutoff (Max) | 1 µA (ICBO) | 10 µA (ICBO) | Substitute higher leakage |
| DC Current Gain (hFE) (Min) | 100 @ 100mA, 5V | 60 @ 700mA, 10V | Main part higher gain |
| Power - Max | 2 W | 25 W | Substitute exceeds requirement |
| Frequency - Transition | 70 MHz | 20 MHz | Substitute rated lower |
| Operating Temperature (TJ) | 150°C | 150°C | Match |
| Mounting Type | Through Hole | Through Hole | Match |
| Package / Case | TO-220-3 | TO-220-3 | Match |
| Moisture Sensitivity Level (MSL) | 1 (Unlimited) | 1 (Unlimited) | Match |
Engineering Selection Recommendations
Substitution Feasibility: The 2SA1668 presents a partial substitution scenario. While the substitute part matches the transistor type, package configuration, operating temperature, and moisture sensitivity level, it exhibits critical deviations in voltage rating and frequency response.
The 2SA1668 is rated for 200 V maximum collector-emitter breakdown voltage, which is 30 V lower than the 2SA1837,WNLF(J) specification of 230 V. This reduction in voltage headroom may introduce reliability concerns in applications operating near the upper voltage limits of the original design.
The 2SA1668 features a transition frequency of 20 MHz, compared to the 2SA1837,WNLF(J) specification of 70 MHz. This represents a significant reduction in high-frequency performance capability and may limit applicability in circuits requiring faster switching or higher-frequency signal processing.
The 2SA1668 is classified as active product status with RoHS3 compliance certification, whereas the 2SA1837,WNLF(J) is obsolete. The substitute part offers superior current handling (2 A versus 1 A) and power dissipation (25 W versus 2 W), along with improved saturation voltage characteristics.
Recommendation: The 2SA1668 is suitable as a substitute only in applications where the 200 V voltage rating and 20 MHz frequency response are compatible with circuit requirements. Applications requiring the full 230 V rating or 70 MHz frequency performance require alternative component selection.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: Can the 2SA1668 directly replace the 2SA1837,WNLF(J) in all applications?
A: No. The 2SA1668 has a lower voltage rating (200 V versus 230 V) and lower transition frequency (20 MHz versus 70 MHz). Substitution is only valid for applications that operate within these reduced specifications.
Q: What is the significance of the voltage rating difference between these parts?
A: The 2SA1837,WNLF(J) is rated for 230 V collector-emitter breakdown voltage, while the 2SA1668 is rated for 200 V. In circuits designed to operate at or near 230 V, the substitute part may experience reduced safety margins or potential failure. Voltage derating analysis is required before substitution.
Q: How does the transition frequency difference affect circuit performance?
A: The 2SA1837,WNLF(J) operates at 70 MHz transition frequency, while the 2SA1668 operates at 20 MHz. In high-frequency switching or signal amplification circuits, the lower frequency rating of the substitute may result in reduced bandwidth, slower switching times, or signal distortion.
Q: Are the package configurations identical?
A: Yes. Both parts use the TO-220-3 through-hole package configuration. Physical mounting and thermal interface compatibility are equivalent.
Q: What are the advantages of the 2SA1668 as a substitute?
A: The 2SA1668 offers higher maximum collector current (2 A versus 1 A), significantly higher power dissipation capability (25 W versus 2 W), lower saturation voltage, and active product status with RoHS3 compliance. These characteristics provide improved thermal performance and supply chain availability.
Q: What is the impact of higher collector cutoff current in the 2SA1668?
A: The 2SA1668 has a maximum collector cutoff current (ICBO) of 10 µA compared to 1 µA in the 2SA1837,WNLF(J). This tenfold increase in leakage current may affect circuit performance in precision analog applications or low-power standby conditions where leakage current is critical.
Q: Is the 2SA1668 suitable for high-frequency switching applications?
A: The 2SA1668 transition frequency of 20 MHz is significantly lower than the 2SA1837,WNLF(J) specification of 70 MHz. For applications requiring switching frequencies above 20 MHz or high-frequency signal processing, the 2SA1668 is not suitable.
Q: What compliance certifications does the 2SA1668 carry?
A: The 2SA1668 is RoHS3 compliant. The 2SA1837,WNLF(J) compliance information is not provided in the available specifications.
Alternative Parts
SJ6012L2TP
Littelfuse Inc.
6 Alternative Parts
JMK107BBJ476MA-RE
Taiyo Yuden
10 Alternative Parts
GMK107BBJ475MA-T
Taiyo Yuden
5 Alternative Parts
SJ6020N2ARP
Littelfuse Inc.
3 Alternative Parts
SJ6025R2ATP
Littelfuse Inc.
4 Alternative Parts
2474-05L
API Delevan Inc.
1 Alternative Parts
4590R-684K
API Delevan Inc.
1 Alternative Parts
CM6560R-334
API Delevan Inc.
1 Alternative Parts
CM6460-104
API Delevan Inc.
1 Alternative Parts
5526-12
API Delevan Inc.
1 Alternative Parts